Showing posts with label India Fisher. Show all posts
Showing posts with label India Fisher. Show all posts

Saturday, January 1, 2011

29. The Chimes of Midnight.


4 episodes. Approx. 116 minutes. Written by: Robert Shearman. Directed by: Barnaby Edwards. Produced by: Gary Russell, Jason Haigh-Ellery.


THE PLOT

It is Christmas Eve, and the TARDIS has materialized inside the larder of an Edwardian mansion circa 1906. When the Doctor and Charley move into the house proper to investigate, they find all the rooms empty. Charley writes her name in the dust on a table, only to watch the dust blow back over it. Some force has locked them outside of time.

Has locked the Doctor out, at least. Charley is let in, just for a moment, and has a conversation with scullery maid Edith Thompson (Louise Rolfe). As they talk, Charley's name appears on the dusty table - and Edith abruptly tells Charley that there will be a murder soon. Hers.

It is an apt prediction. As the chimes of a grandfather clock are heard striking the hour, a woman's screams fill the air. The Doctor and Charley find themselves standing over Edith's body. The rest of the household staff also appears, with the stern butler Shaughnessy (Lennox Greaves) recognizing the Doctor and Charley as detectives who will surely solve this case. An hour later, another murder occurs. But the hour has passed in only half the time it should have, and the staff appears bizarrely unconcerned by the deaths.

Time continues to speed up, and the dead return to life only to be murdered again. As the Doctor comes to see that they are trapped in a time loop, Charley is visited by Edith's ghost, who tells her to remember her - And also one more thing:

"Edward Grove is alive..."


CHARACTERS

The Doctor: When the TARDIS materializes in a place that's completely dark, with no readings to indicate where and when they are, he is initially delighted at the prospect of a mystery. But once he realizes that there is an intelligent force at work, he attempts escape. "There are some mysteries best left unsolved," he tells Charley, readily admitting that he's frightened. He observes that they're being left far too many clues about the murders, and that the murders themselves are little more than red herrings. Paul McGann is superb throughout - doubly so in the final episode, as he attempts to reason first with the villain of the piece and then with Charley herself, in a scene that's a major turning point in their particular Doctor/Companion dynamic.

Charley: Though this house is larger than the one in which she grew up, she is very much a part of this culture. She instantly recognizes the servants' rooms for what they are, guiding both Doctor and listener through this confined space in Episode One to set the geography for the rest of the story. As they look over the Christmas preparations, she casually complains that "cook used to make far too much (plum pudding)," and it is evident from her comments that she never really picked up on the names of her family's own servants. The cook was just "Cook," defined by her role in the household just as the servants in this story are defined entirely by their roles. The force at work recognizes her as "belonging," and works her into a role as well: As the daughter of the Master of the House, a role she gradually finds impossible to resist.


THOUGHTS

"How can I be dead and alive at the same time...?"

Doctor Who's best Christmas story was not any of the new series' Christmas specials. It was not made for television at all, and it wasn't even released at Christmas. Which, in a story focused on paradoxes, seems oddly perfect - Much like the rest of The Chimes of Midnight.

Writer Robert Shearman's first Big Finish audio was The Holy Terror, a tremendously well-received story that helped raise the bar of what the audience expected of the company. The Chimes of Midnight not only doesn't disappoint; it raises that bar even further. It is surreal but not nonsensical, funny but emotional. It also features the most multilayered characterizations yet for the likeable Eighth Doctor/Charley team.

Shearman builds on previously established character traits, and uses those to fuel the story. Charley's privileged background makes her a ready-made guide to the basic layout of the servant's hall. Her intrinsic compassion also fuels the narrative through her connection with the murdered Edith - a connection that starts as Edith reacts to Charley's kindness, a trait she has encountered far too little of.  That connection grows over the story, and twists into something dark and sinister as the episodes progress.

The script doesn't forget to give the Doctor excellent material as well. It's a treat to hear Paul McGann's usually laid-back Doctor be genuinely afraid. He finds himself a step behind throughout: First genuinely trying to solve Edith's murder, then trying to prevent the next, before it occurs to him that the murders themselves are incidental. At one point he actually gives up, ready to abandon the servants to loop about eternally in their tiny circles. Only when the mysterious Edward Grove confronts him directly does he find an opportunity for victory - an opportunity that hinges on his own connection with Charley.

In a stunning speech, he lays out for Charley what she means to him, drawing a direct line between his solo existence and the loop in which they are all trapped: "Without you, I would just be a lonely old man, rattling around in the TARDIS with no one to talk to: My life going round and round without meaning, my life going around in circles." The speech, in its full length both emotional and poetic, is superbly delivered by McGann and is one that will go 'round and 'round within the listener's mind after the story is done. It marks the point at which his relationship with Charley ceases to be just a standard Doctor/Companion relationship. After this, they are almost equal leads for the next several stories and genuinely close friends.

The ending ties it all together with a lovely grace note, one that could have been cloying had it not been so very well earned by the time it occurs. In a more standard episode, the exact same scene with the exact same dialogue might have made me roll my eyes or groan. But coming at the end of a story that has built so well to it, the final fade out on a poor girl's humming of Hark, the Herald Angels Sing is remarkably effective.

With terrific performances (Lennox Greaves' Shaughnessy is a particular standout, and I wish I had space to give him the full praises due to him), and a wonderfully creepy yet authentic-seeming soundscape under the guiding hand of director Barnaby Edwards, The Chimes of Midnight is as close to perfect as a story can be. Well over a decade after the fact, it remains a strong contender for the title of best Big Finish audio, and is one of the best Doctor Who stories available in any form.


Overall Rating: 10/10.

Previous Story: Invaders from Mars
Next Story: Seasons of Fear (not yet reviewed)

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

8th Doctor Audio Review Index

8th Doctor Television Review Index

Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

28. Invaders from Mars.


4 episodes. Approx. 94 minutes. Written by: Mark Gatiss. Directed by: Mark Gatiss. Produced by: Gary Russell, Jason Haigh-Ellery.


THE PLOT

Manhattan. October, 1938. The Mercury Theatre on the Air is preparing its Halloween episode, a piece the show's star and creator considers a minor piece of fluff to get through before tackling more important works. This Halloween special is an adaptation of H. G. Wells' The War of the Worlds, and it is destined to become the most famous performance of a radio play in history - and a star-making moment for young actor/writer/director Orson Welles (David Benson).

The Doctor and Charley are also in New York, the TARDIS having slightly overshot an attempt to deliver Charley to her rendezvous in Singapore. They are barely out of the timeship before stumbling - almost literally - over a dead body. The corpse is that of a private detective named Halliday, and his death clearly came at the hands of technology that could not exist on Earth in this time period!

The Doctor's investigation plunges him into plots and counterplots involving spies both American and Russian, a ruthless but patriotic New York mobster known as Don Chaney (Simon Pegg), and gossip columnist Cosmo Devine (John Arthur), a secret Nazi sympathizer despite being openly and flamboyantly homosexual. All of them are after the same prize: The very alien technology the Doctor seeks, which crashed to Earth one month earlier.

But technology wasn't all that crashed to Earth. And even as Orson Welles broadcasts his realistic, news-style report of alien invasion, real extra-terrestrials land in the city, with plans of conquest.

As one of the aliens declares: "We'll take Manhattan! And Staten Island, too!"


CHARACTERS

The Doctor:
 The involvement of alien technology would have drawn his attention regardless - but he still finds the chance to "play detective" in 1930's New York irresistible.  When Halliday's client, Glory Bee (Jessica Stevenson), is revealed to be other than she appears, he says it was foolish of him not to guess - though his manner and the lack of shock in his voice indicate that he had already guessed and was just playing along. He goes into full fanboy mode upon meeting Orson Welles, revealing that he's seen all of his movies (much to the confusion of a Welles who has yet to make any) and unable to resist blurting out: "Don't let them cut Ambersons!"

Charley: Urgently wants to make her Singapore rendezvous, but otherwise seems in no rush to leave the Doctor. Though she shows some mild exasperation at his attempt to talk like a 1930's gumshoe, her fondness and faith in him is clear throughout. When Devine drugs her to get her to talk, what she reveals is her faith that the Doctor will stop "the meddling." She even laughs at Devine's antics, referring to him as "Canut," directly recalling the Doctor's story about Canut's attempt to turn back the tide.

Orson Welles: This story's major historical guest character, though he's largely on the periphery of the main action until the very end. For the first three episodes, Welles' role is a dramatization of the production of the War of the Worlds broadcast, with only minor crossovers with the Who story. David Benson's Welles barely possesses a fraction of the real Welles' enormous presence, but he sounds close enough to the real thing that it's very easy to accept him in the role, and his banter with "Jack" Houseman (Jonathan Rigby) is consistently enjoyable throughout. The serial barely scratches the surface of the brilliant yet unreliable, driven yet self-sabotaging auteur... But if it's a shallow sketch, it at least feels right within the broadstrokes, the Welles scenes melding nicely with the more fantastical material surrounding him.


THOUGHTS

The notion of an actual alien invasion being staged against the backdrop of Orson Welles' infamous War of the Worlds radio play is hardly original (among other works, it formed part of the backbone for cult classic The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai), but it remains an irresistible flight of fancy. And while Mark Gatiss may be very far from my favoriteWho writer, he has proved in his larger career that he has a deft touch with comedy. Invaders from Mars, an unapologetic comedy pastische, makes full use of Gatiss' strengths, and it remains highly enjoyable many years after its initial release.

Simon Pegg is the high-profile guest star, and he does a capable job playing the ruthless yet likable Don Chaney. But the top acting honors go to John Arthur, whose Cosmo Devine flat-out steals the show. Arthur takes this flamboyantly gay villain and makes him into a distinct character: Smart, silky, and with just enough of an edge to be genuinely threatening while remaining amusing. The story is at its best when Devine is center-stage.

Not that it gets a chance to lose steam when he's offstage. At 94 minutes, this is one of Big Finish's shorter releases. Gatiss' script is lean and fast. Every scene advances the story, and most scenes are short and snappy. In many respects, it evokes the screwball comedies of the era in which it's set: Rapid-fire dialogue and an abundance of comic energy. This is a story that actually improves on repeat visits - I suspect because it all goes by so quickly that you're bound to miss something the first time around.

Pure comedy Doctor Who is relatively rare, and usually not very good - But this one works like a treat. It's featherweight - But it's also a whole lot of fun.

Overall Rating: 7/10.

Previous Story: Minuet in Hell
Next Story: The Chimes of Midnight 

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who



Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Friday, December 31, 2010

19. Minuet in Hell.


4 episodes. Approx. 145 minutes. Written by: Alan W. Lear, Gary Russell. Directed by: Nicholas Briggs. Produced by: Gary Russell, Jason Haigh-Ellery.


THE PLOT

The 51st state has been added to the Union: Malebolgia, a chunk of territory in the Bible Belt that has seceded in order to form its own state (don't think too hard about the unlikely politics...). Former Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart (Nicholas Courtney) is on-hand to observe the birth of this new state. But he's here for another reason, as well: To investigate the Dashwood Laboratory of Alternative Mentalities - an advanced mental hospital whose new treatment, involving a machine that can digitally store patients' memories as they undergo brain surgery, has raised concerns about mind control.

The hospital is owned by television evangelist Brigham Elisha Dashwood (Robert Jezek), who is manipulating all those around him to make sure that he will become governor of the new state. He has created a "Hellfire Club," a recreation of the famous/infamous gathering place of 18th Century Britain, run by his own ancestor, Sir Francis Dashwood. Here, he allows all the highest-ranking corrupt politicos to run rampant with their worst desires... all the while capturing their debauchery on videotape for future use.

This Hellfire Club doesn't so much employ young women of easy virtue as kidnap them off the streets. The newest arrival is a young English girl with strong ideas about what she'll do to anyone who touches her improperly. Dashwood's asylum has a couple of new arrivals, both also English: Gideon Crane (Nicholas Briggs), a journalist investigating Dashwood's institute; and "Zebediah Doe," a particularly confused man who insists both that he is a Time Lord from the planet Gallifrey, and that he is in Hell - the one place from which he can never escape!


CHARACTERS

The Doctor:
 Spends most of the story in a fractured state, his mind and memories having been jumbled just prior to the story's opening. This gives McGann a chance to do some pretty good insane acting. He mumbles a mile a minute, and you can almost see the Doctor's thoughts jumping from track to track as he tries to orientate himself. We get a flash of his usual persona as he remembers something, as some piece slots into place - Then see him falter into confusion and despair as the connection slips away. The Doctor only properly recovers in the final episode when, finally in command of his faculties, he takes complete charge, sorting a very messy situation with efficiency and elan.

Charley: Gets stuck with the traditional companion dilemma of being captured and escaping, only to end up recaptured. Fortunately, India Fisher's enthusiasm keeps the character strong even when some of the material she's given is weak. She is familiar with the legend of the British Hellfire Club (the Doctor reveals the less glamorous reality of it at the end), and can't help but be fascinated to see a revival. Though she only meets the Brigadier fairly briefly, he makes a strong impression on her... which doesn't stop her from ribbing the Doctor for calling him his best friend when he called her the same just a single story ago.

Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart: It was a natural decision to end the first Eighth Doctor audio season with an appearance by the Brigadier, in order to allow Nicholas Courtney to - as Paul McGann put it - "complete the set" of classic Doctors. Courtney is in marvelous form, as is the character. Lethbridge-Stewart retains a natural authority, enough to cut short Sen. Waldo Pickering (Morgan Deare)'s temper tantrum at the institute in Episode One and enough to catch Dashwood's eye straight off. He is also at his shrewdest here, recognizing that something is not right about Dashwood's entire operation. He only has a small amount of "screen time" opposite McGann, but the two play well off each other and it's a shame that Zagreus was the only other story to feature both of them.


THOUGHTS

"That's it - Now I understand! Everyone in the universe is the Doctor! Everyone except me!"
-The Doctor faces a most bizarre identity crisis.

Minuet in Hell is generally the worst-regarded story of McGann's first Big Finish season, and I can't argue with the criticims of it. It's not just overlong - at almost two-and-a-half hours, it's positively bloated, which has earned it the nickname "150 Minuets in Hell." The Inside Story, Big Finish's warts-and-all overview of its first 50 releases, reveals that it had a very troubled history. Writer Alan W. Lear was hired to adapt his old Audio-Visuals story for the Eighth Doctor, but was only able to (more or less) pen the first half. Producer Gary Russell was left to throw together the second half on a very tight timetable... Which may explain why the second half is both a lot less crazy and (sadly) a lot less fun.

The story is unconvincing on any number of levels. Neither Dashwood nor Pickering convince as formidable political figures, and the backstory - involving a new Southern state coming into being via secession - is laughable to anyone with a passing knowledge of American politics. Morgan Deare's Waldo Pickering is downright painful to listen to, with speech patterns and dialogue culled from Yosemite Sam and Foghorn Leghorn cartoons. Pickering's every statement seems to be punctuated with either a "varmint" or a "tarnation," if not both. People not only don't talk that way in the modern American South... I don't think they ever actually did!

For all its problems (and there are many that I won't even bother mentioning), I have no hate for Minuet in Hell. For three of its four episodes, it is so over-the-top and downright nutty that it's actually rather fun. You've got: overblown Southern-fried accents; demonic possessions; technobabble surrounding the "Psi859 Psionic Matrix Facsimile Regenerator" that would make Star Trek: Voyager blush; and a story whose two main settings are a modern-day Hellfire Club and an insane asylum. If Salvador Dali tried his hand at Southern Gothic, then had the results reinterpreted by Tex Avery and filtered through the sensibilities of Ralph Bakshi, it's not hard to picture something like this as the result.

But Episode Four is tasked with taking all of this insanity and wrapping it up in a way that can at least pretend to make sense. Other than a brief bit with Charley being rejected by demons for being "already dead" (a nice reminder of her arc, which would take off in a big way the following year), the final episode feels joyless. We spend too long setting up Dashwood's television broadcast, so that we're well-prepared when the Doctor, the Brigadier, and Charley replicate the ending of A Face in the Crowd to defeat him. Then, since there's still a subplot involving a demon to wrap up (yes, the demon is a subplot), we get an additional climax in the institute, one that requires Dashwood to transform into a complete imbecile in order for events to progress as they do.

I can't exactly recommend this story, which is as ridiculous as it is ridiculously overlong. But there is a lot to enjoy here, with terrific performances by the regulars and by guest stars Nicholas Courtney and Robert Jezek. Worth a listen for completists... but probably OK to skip by everyone else.


Overall Rating: 5/10.

Previous Story: The Stones of Venice
Next Story: Invaders from Mars

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who



Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

18. The Stones of Venice.


4 episodes. Approx. 111 minutes. Written by: Paul Magrs. Directed by: Gary Russell. Produced by: Gary Russell, Jason Haigh-Ellery.


THE PLOT

The Doctor takes Charley on a trip to Venice - specifically, to Venice in 2294, on the eve of its final sinking. 100 years previously, the ruling Duke Orcino (Michael Sheard) gambled away his beloved wife, Estella, in a game of chance. Shocked at his betrayal, Estella cursed Orcino and his city to 100 more years of life, followed by destruction. In the decades since, a cult has developed worshipping her as one would a goddess, insisting that she will return to save them all.

The Doctor has little interest in obscure cults, sinking cities, or old curses. But he is interested in saving the duke's art collection, presided over by the long-suffering Churchwell (Nick Scovell). His eye is captured by paintings that don't belong - paintings that literally should not exist on Earth.

Meanwhile, Charley is drawn to Pietro (Barnaby Edwards), a gondolier who observes that she and the Doctor seem less frivolous and more thoughtful than most of the gentry. The gondoliers have evolved into an amphibious underclass, awaiting the waters will close over the highest of Venice's spires and the city will become theirs. Pietro fears that Orcino may yet find a way to break the curse, but Charley's arrival presents an opportunity - one he takes by drugging the girl and presenting her as the reincarnation of the Lady Estella!


CHARACTERS

The Doctor:
 Separated from Charley, pursued by cultists, and faced with the prospect of confronting a corrupt and apparently deranged Duke... and this Doctor is all but flying on the joy of it. He exults to Churchwell about the exhileration that comes with the danger, seeming genuinely surprised that the other man doesn't share the feeling. He remains protective of Charley, clearly feeling responsible for her well-being - but his evasive response to her comment about eventually returning home shows that he still hasn't decided what he's going to do with her.

Charley: Feels genuine compassion for the gondoliers, oppressed for centuries by a decadent ruling class. But her headstrong nature makes her easy prey for their plan to distract the duke. She sneaks away as soon as she sees an opportunity, and to her credit is able to talk Pietro into seeing the pointlessness of his attempted distraction, but quickly changes gears when the Doctor arrives. Gets possibly her best scene to date in Episode Four. When Orcino barks threateningly at her, she doesn't get behind the Doctor, but instead stares the aristocrat down, pointing out how this entire situation is the fault of his own moral weakness.

Duke Orcino: Michael Sheard, who guest-starred in Who stories in the '60's, the '70's, and the '80's, gives his final series bow in the only form in which it existed in the early 2000's: audio. The dissolute Count Orcino wallows in his own guilt and depression - in the words of the waspish Miss Lavish, wasting all the extra years cursed upon him by his beloved Estella. That curse could as easily have been a gift: With an extra century of life, a more driven or ambitious man could have accomplished much. All Orcino has done is pined after the woman he lost through his own foolishness, lounging uselessly on his meaningless throne. The rising waters are irrelevant - This man has already drowned himself in a dingy sea of self-pity: The story's theme of corruption and decay in human form.


THOUGHTS

"The hands of the clock are meeting... And the clock chimes out for the death of Venice!"
-The Doctor, realizing that time has run out for the sinking city.

The Stones of Venice has long stood as easily my favorite of the four stories making up Paul McGann's first Big Finish "season." It's another wonderful production, the soundscape bringing to life the canals of the gondoliers, the gaudy palace of the duke, and the catacombs in which the cult makes its lair. McGann is at his most enthusiastic, and writer Paul Magrs' script is a wonderfully literate modern fairy tale.

It is easy to see that this may not be for all tastes. With a story involving what is essentially a witch's curse, foregrounding themes of corruption and decay in a city that's perpetually sinking, this is much more a modern fable than science fiction. The narrative voice is best personified in the character of Miss Lavish (Elaine Ives-Cameron), a waspish crone who observes the city's final night and the actions of the characters (Doctor and Charley included) with sardonic disdain:

"Crazed aristocrats, madmen, inveterate revelers, all of them here for the final carnival of all... Expecting to see the place rise to its former glories all of its own accord, magically. There isn't any such thing as magic... Nothing is going to happen here. The pattern is set, more's the pity!"

Mind you, that very sardonic distance undercuts any sense of threat or tension. Much as I enjoy this story, I can see why some find it slow going. The actual narrative is paper-thin, with the characters largely just waiting for dawn and the death of Venice. The closest thing to a villain the story has is the cult: A generic bunch, whose bearing and masked garb is mocked even by the Doctor. There's an end twist of sorts, but I have difficulty believing anyone hadn't figured it out by the end of Episode One, let alone by the time it finally comes to fruition in Episode Four.

But narrative drive isn't the focus, and it isn't the very basic plot that provides the pleasure in listening. It's the atmosphere. Paul Magrs' characters don't speak to advance plot points: They soliloquize, building pictures and moods with their words and lending flesh and form to this fairy tale future Venice. Russell Stone's score adds further layers to the ambience: light and sprightly when following the Doctor and Charley, so vivacious that they seem to all but dance as they speak; slow and melancholy when enveloping the dissipated Orcino or the embittered Miss Lavish, as if they are standing witness to a funeral in heavy rain.

For me, the almost literary use of language and the marvelously atmospheric production easily outweigh the sketchy plot, leaving me awarding a generous...


Overall Rating: 8/10.

Previous Story: Sword of Orion
Next Story: Minuet in Hell

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

8th Doctor Audio Review Index

8th Doctor Television Review Index

Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

17. Sword of Orion.


4 episodes. Approx. 123 minutes. Written by: Nicholas Briggs. Directed by: Nicholas Briggs. Produced by: Gary Russell, Jason Haigh-Ellery.


THE PLOT

The Doctor brings Charley to the Garazone System, home to a bazaar where one can find almost anything - hopefully including a cure for Ramsay, the vortisaur who rescued them from the crash of the R101. Ramsay has fallen ill due to separation from the Time Vortex, and now is too weak to be returned to his "natural habitat." But while he and Charley browse the bazaar, the TARDIS is loaded onto the scrap ship Vanguard, leaving the time travelers with no choice but to stow away before the ship takes off.

The Vanguard is under the command of a new captain, Deeva Jansen (Michelle Livingstone) - A woman who does not appear to belong among these mercenary salvagers. Deeva is possessed of a military efficiency, and delivers orders with the certainty of someone used to being obeyed without question. She plots a very specific course, one that brings the Vanguard directly to a derelict star destroyer, a find that other scrap ships have left alone because it's too big to salvage.

She orders her crew to spacewalk over to the derelict. The ship initially appears empty, its systems heavily damaged by an ion storm. But they all too soon discover its inhabitants: Cybermen. They rode out the storm in a state of hibernation. Now that the storm has passed, they are starting to awaken, with only one purpose in their cybernetic minds:

Conversion!


CHARACTERS

The Doctor:
 As the synopsis above shows, the Doctor doesn't really have a very proactive role in this story. Once he and Charley are aboard the Vanguard, their main goal for the rest of the story is simply to reach the TARDIS and escape. Once it becomes clear that the derelict star destroyer is a Cyber-ship, the Doctor does use his ingenuity to try to keep the salvage crew alive... but the person truly driving the action in the Cyber plot is Deeva, with the main complications provided by the ruthless Grash (Bruce Montague), leaving the Doctor largely reacting to events as they unfold. Paul McGann remains as game here as he was in Storm Warning, however, which helps to make the Doctor's role feel more central than it truly is.

Charley: India Fisher remains an engaging co-star, showing a strong interplay with Paul McGann and giving a lot of emotion and expression in her line deliveries. Charley herself gets less to do in this story, however, largely filling generic companion functions. She's held hostage by the salvage crew while the Doctor and Deeva explore the Cyber-ship. Once reunited with the Doctor, she tags along with him, following his lead. The script also gives her a few too many smug quips, particularly in the first half, undercutting the character's inherent likability a bit.

Cybermen: This story presents the Cybermen in a weakened state. Their ship and systems have been crippled by an ion storm, and they are only able to awaken from hibernation one Cyberman at a time. This allows for a slow burn in the story's first half. A "rogue Cyberman," deranged due to storm damage, kills a crew member at the end of Part One, before being killed in turn. A Cybermat smuggles itself aboard the Vanguard, sabotaging the scrap ship and making it impossible for the humans to simply escape. But this also makes it impossible for the Cybermen to escape. With their ship's shields already destroyed, the next ion storm will eradicate them. Even so, they carry on with their directive, working to capture and convert the Vanguard crew, even when all that will accomplish is giving them a handful of additional Cybermen to be destroyed when the storm hits.


THOUGHTS

Sword of Orion is an example of what I tend to call "Saward Who." Like (too) many stories from Eric Saward's tenure as script editor, the story's guest cast is stuffed with unpleasant mercenary characters who spend at least as much time menacing the Doctor as working with him. There is a sense of nihilism throughout, and as the body count rises in the final episodes, it ultimately leaves events feeling less tragic than pointless.

The story's characters are a grim lot. Grash is a borderline psychopath; the crew members are alternately selfish, cowardly, and stupid; Deeva, whom we are encouraged to find sympathetic, is cold and hides an agenda that would have far-reaching and devastating consequences. But the story is well-made and well-paced, and somehow the characters manage to work within the framework they're given.

Part of this rests in Nicholas Briggs finding moments to give to each of them. Grash may be a murderous criminal, but it's clear that he's genuinely appalled and angry at the death of one of his men. The final episode of the story gives him a moment that's pitiable even as it's a moment of triumph, as he reponds to Cyber-conversion by spitting out increasingly insane threats. His mind is apparently broken, but he wins his battle of will, as the Cybermen dub him "unsuitable for conversion." And though we have no reason to particularly care about Ike, Chev, or Vol, the scenes in which they're in jeopardy are individually gripping. That's in addition to Deeva's final (somewhat cliched) act of personal heroism. The characters are dingy and sleazy people in a dingy and sleazy world, but there's just enough human dignity in them to make this work on a level other than that of a well-produced slasher flick.

It is particularly well-produced, even by Big Finish's generally reliable standards. The doors of the scrap ship squeal, speaking to the lax maintenance. On the Cyber-ship, footsteps echo with a wonderfully ominous quality, and spooky, shadow-filled visuals are conjured in the mind. Gone is the labored visual exposition that marred the otherwise very good Storm Warning - A mix of subtle dialogue cues and sound effects are trusted to create the pictures. Writer/director Nicholas Briggs also composes the incidental score, a very mechanical one well-suited to the Cybermen, and highly effective in evoking the dark, ominous atmosphere.

But that bitter "Saward Who" aftertaste lingers, keeping me from fully embracing this story despite having been engrossed in it while listening. A little too much like stories from the Saward era, the Doctor's role feels a bit too perfunctory. He and Charley are present for events, but they aren't very proactive. The Doctor is largely just present. Briggs' script allows him a few moments of cleverness, most notably the bit in Episode Three in which he sabotages the airlock to thwart the Cybermen's attempted invasion of the Vanguard. But he doesn't really drive the action, he just reacts to it. The main guest character, Deeva, ends up doing a lot more to drive the plot than the Doctor does.

The story is well-made and it provides an engrossing two-hour diversion. But the unpleasant characters, the Doctor's weak role, and the overall sense of futility keep this from being anything more than average in my view.


Overall Rating: 6/10.

Previous Story: Storm Warning
Next Story: The Stones of Venice

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

8th Doctor Audio Review Index

8th Doctor Television Review Index

Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

16. Storm Warning.


4 episodes. Approx. 116 minutes. Written by: Alan Barnes. Directed by: Gary Russell. Produced by: Gary Russell, Jason Haigh-Ellery.


THE PLOT

The R101, the ill-fated British airship that was to be the world's largest airship until the construction of the (similarly-fated) Hindenburg, sets off on its fateful voyage to Karachi. Lieutenant-Colonel Frayling (Nicholas Pegg), the ship's designer, is concerned about last-minute modifications imposed by the blustery Lord Tamworth (Gareth Thomas). Tamworth insists the ship is "safe as houses," all the while refusing to explain why it was rushed into this trip before testing was complete. He is similarly closed-mouthed about the exact role of his valet, the sinister Rathbone (Barnaby Edwards), or the nature of the mysterious passenger in Cabin 43.

The airship also carries two stowaways. Charlotte "Charley" Pollard (India Fisher) is a self-styled "Edwardian adventuress" who sneaked aboard by assuming the identity of a young steward. When Tamworth notices that the supposed boy is actually a girl, she flees - and runs straight into the second stowaway, the grinning and gregarious man known only as the Doctor (Paul McGann).

The Doctor smooths things over by passing himself and Charley off as German spies, sent by the Zeppelin corporation to uncover the secrets of the R101. Tamworth is pleased; he would have been insulted had no attempt been made, and the Doctor's obvious familiarity with the airship's workings make him an advisor with good reason to be cooperative. He reveals to them that the passenger in Cabin 43 is actually an extra-terrestrial: A member of a race known as the Triskele (Helen Goldwyn), whose ship crashed the previous year. Using a medium as a go-between, Tamworth was able to arrange a mid-air rendezvous with the Triskele mothership, in order to return this lone engineer and to negotiate with the aliens.

But that isn't the full extent of Tamworth's purpose. Should his negotiations fail, Rathbone has orders of his own. Orders that may just kick-start the Earth's first interplanetary war...


CHARACTERS

The Doctor:
Storm Warning marks Paul McGann's return to the role of the 8th Doctor, for the first time since the Earth & Beyond audio book in 1998. McGann jumps in with both feet, showing the same enthusiasm and joy for life that made him so instantly engaging in the (otherwise very flawed) 1996 TV Movie. He has a disarming manner that makes it easy for Lord Tamworth to accept his cover story of being a German spy, and that encourages Charley to trust him even before she believes a word that he's saying. His sense of responsibility to the Web of Time forms a major building block of this narrative, and helps to cement the arc that will spring from this tale.

Charley: When Big Finish decided to create a plucky, rebellious, upper-class girl to accompany the Eighth Doctor on his new adventures, it is little surprise that they brought in India Fisher - The role is all but identical to Peril Bellamy in Winter for the Adept, and Fisher's performance was practically the only distinguishing feature of an otherwise relentlessly bland outing. The emphasis here is to introduce Charley's major characteristics: That she is resourceful, compassionate, and courageous. She gets to show all of these traits at multiple points, with her compassionate streak particularly brought out in her interactions with the injured Treskele. Her headstrong young English girl makes a good fit with this breathless, young-ish Doctor, though any real character depth would have to wait for future stories.

Lord Tamworth: Blake's Seven's Gareth Thomas makes him Big Finish debut in this story's major guest role, and he is a delight. Tamworth, a stand-in for Lord Thomson in the real R101 incident, is full of bluster and bravado. He's not above threatening to destroy Lt. Col. Frayling's career if he interferes with his mission, and avows that he'll have Charley's "guts for garters" when he discovers she has snuck aboard the airship. But Episode Three reveals another side to him, showing how haunted he is by his experiences in the Great War and how determined he is that such a conflict never be repeated. Thomas is terrific throughout, and his enthusiastic portrayal gives the story a considerable boost.


THOUGHTS

Storm Warning was Big Finish's first Eighth Doctor adventure, and in 2001 that was a very big deal not only for the company, but for Doctor Who as a whole. There was no new series at that time, not even a glimmer of one on the horizon. The Eighth Doctor was the current face of Who; and save for Earth & Beyond, the only performed McGann story was The TV Movie. It was here that the series began moving forward again, with the then-current Doctor getting new stories carrying him forward in a performed medium. Those stories were even presented as "seasons," at a time when that was not Big Finish's norm. In a very real way, Storm Warning marked the return of Doctor Who as a current series, if not yet one that was on television.

It also stands up as a rather good story.

A quick perusal of Wikipedia turns up plenty of ways in which the story deviates from history: The real R101 received a lot more testing than is indicated the story indicates, for example, including multiple short flights before the fatal trip to India. There were also a very small number of survivors of the real crash, something Barnes' script alters for dramatic convenience. Still, it makes an ideal setting for a Who story, with a physical structure that is very easy to visualize and a confined setting that naturally thrusts characters together.

Story structure is quite sound, with Episode One quickly sketching that Lord Tamworth is using this flight to complete a secret mission, that Rathbone is helping him, and that there is something unusual about the passenger in Cabin 43. It brings the Doctor and Charley together, then ends on a cliffhanger. Episode Two expands on this, as the Doctor interacts with Tamworth while Charley interacts with Rathbone and the passenger. Secrets start to be peeled back, and it ends on a note that shifts the story's tone for the second half. Episode Three provides the major exposition, and Episode Four resolves the situation and sets up the complicated situation with Charley for future stories.

Alan Barnes' script does intermittently suffer from the bane of good audio stories: Clunky visual descriptions. The opening scenes are the worst in this regard: The Doctor talks to himself nonstop, helpfully describing a crash in the Time Vortex (which a later story would revisit to good effect) and the vortisaurs picking over the debris of the crash. This eases off for most of the rest of Episode One, but returns for the Episode Two cliffhanger, in which the arrival of the Triskele is described in far too much detail. We could have been to fill in that the alien ship is big, for instance, without having a character describe its dimensions for us.

Overall, however, the Eighth Doctor's Big Finish audio debut does a fine job of reintroducing an incarnation who had been restricted to print for far too long. Paul McGann gives a spirited performance, and he and India Fisher make for a likable and energetic team. The story itself is satisfying - and even more important, it leaves you wanting to hear more stories with this team.


Overall Rating: 7/10.

Next Story: Sword of Orion


8th Doctor Audio Review Index

8th Doctor Television Review Index

Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

10. Winter for the Adept.


4 episodes. Approx. 94 minutes. Written by: Andrew Cartmel. Directed by: Gary Russell. Produced by: Jason Haigh-Ellery, Gary Russell. 


THE PLOT

One of the Doctor's experiments leaves Nyssa teleported to the Swiss Alps in 1963 in the dead of winter. She is rescued by Lieutenant Sandoz (Peter Jurasik), a Swiss police officer who takes her to the nearest shelter: A girls' finishing school run by the fanatically religious Miss Tremayne (Sally Faulkner). 

Most of the girls at the school have gone home to spend Christmas with their families. But a snowstorm has left two teen girls stranded: 15-year-old Alison Spears (Liz Sutherland) and her rebellious friend, 19-year-old Peril Bellamy (India Fisher). The school has problems beyond the storm. A series of incidents has left Miss Tremayne convinced that "the spirits of the dead" are haunting them. Not long after Nyssa arrives, the electric lights go out, a mirror breaks, and the glass shards of the mirror rise up to attack!

When the Doctor finally arrives, he can't help but investigate this apparent genuine haunting. But Lt. Sandoz is suspicious of his unusual arrival, Miss Tremayne is becoming increasingly irrational, and Peril and Alison are hiding secrets of their own. As the poltergeist activity grows ever more violent, the Doctor realizes that something more is at work - and that all of the humans may be pawns in a deadlier game...


CHARACTERS

The Doctor:
 The Doctor doesn't appear until the very end of Episode One, making him all the more dominant for the wait. Peter Davison is on terrific form, very funny in his understated way while still anchoring the story with his steady presence. I particularly enjoyed his interplay with Lt. Sandoz (Peter Jurasik). The Doctor shows disdain for Sandoz in every scene they share. Most of this is amusing, as when he belittles the other man's stubborn skepticism by noting, "You'll end up cutting your throat with Occam's Razor," or swipes at Sandoz's attempts to take charge by saying, "Yes, I thought it had been a while since you 'demanded' something." But he also bristles with moral outrage when Sandoz shoots another character - unnecessarily, in the Doctor's view, though any country's police would deem it a justified shooting.

Nyssa: When writer Andrew Cartmel got the brief to write a 5th Doctor/Nyssa adventure, did he get Nyssa confused with Tegan? That's the only explanation I can come up with for Nyssa's uncharacteristic bad temper in this story. I have no problem with her irritation in Episode One and even early Episode Two - After all, being abruptly dumped into the middle of the Swiss Alps in your street clothes would take anyone aback. But she remains irritable all the way through the story. Simply put: I don't know who it is Sarah Sutton is playing in this story, but it sure isn't Nyssa of Traken.


THOUGHTS

Winter for the Adept has the ingredients necessary to be a very good Doctor Who story. There's an isolated, near-deserted school for girls, two young girls with secrets, a suspicious and trigger-happy police lieutenant, a fanatically religious headmistress, and an increasingly violent poltergeist haunting. Mix in an excellent, atmospheric music score by Russell Stone, and you have everything needed to create one of Big Finish's best early stories.

Unfortunately, that doesn't end up being the result. The blame for that lands squarely on writer Andrew Cartmel, who fails to make full use of his very promising ingredients.

The squandered potential is evident. Early in the story, Nyssa notes how strong an impression the Doctor has made on Alison. Not long after, strong hints are dropped that Alison is jealous of Nyssa's place with the Doctor, a plot and character element that is... completely dropped, and evidently forgotten as Alison fades ever further into the background. 

Miss Tremayne's religious fixation is similarly underutilized. Much is made of it in the first episode. Then she overhears a conversation indicating that at least one of her young charges has psychic abilities and whispers,"Though shalt not suffer a witch to live." This pronouncement receives only one scene of follow-up, as Tremayne attempts to act in the most cartoonish manner possible when more drama might have been milked had she been more willing to wait for an opportunity to strike.

Instead of properly using characters from whom conflict and jeopardy could obviously have been wrung, Cartmel takes his script on a left turn into an entirely different story. To make matters worse, this happens about halfway through Episode Four, as we shift from a decent enough little ghost story to a rushed alien invasion scenario. With only about ten minutes of story left, that subplot is wrapped up almost as quickly as it's introduced, leaving the story to end on a very weak note. 

Had the alien invasion subplot been dropped entirely and the potential for conflict among the human characters been more fully explored, this might have been a first-rate audio adventure. As it stands, it's not really bad. The first three episodes are mostly enjoyable, with a sprinking of good scenes and good overall performances. It's also notable as India Fisher's first Doctor Who audio, with her performance here surely responsible for her casting as Charley Pollard in the Eighth Doctor audios. 

But the squandered potential of this gathering of guest characters, and the ill-advised decision to shift from ghost story to invasion story far too late in the narrative... I would rate these as missteps that derail the story. For three episodes, I was leaning toward awarding this a "6." The final episode, and particularly the final ten minutes, knocked my score significantly downward.


Overall Rating: 4/10.

Previous Story: The Land of the Dead
Next Story: The Mutant Phase 

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

5th Doctor Audio Review Index

5th Doctor Television Review Index

Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads: