Showing posts with label Time Lords. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Time Lords. Show all posts

Sunday, March 6, 2011

123-a. The Company of Friends: Benny's Story.


1 episode. Approx. 35 minutes. Written by: Lance Parkin. Directed by: Nicholas Briggs.  Produced by: David Richardson.


THE PLOT

Many years after the end of her association with the Doctor, archaeologist Bernice Summerfield is participating in a dig inside the coal mines of a dead planet. It's a freelance job for which she is being very well-paid, in exchange for "not asking any questions." She is shocked when she quickly finds the object of her employer’s efforts: a TARDIS key. She is even more startled when her employer uses that key to summon the TARDIS in question – the TARDIS belonging to the Doctor!

Soon, Benny finds herself running with the Doctor from deadly security robots, through frozen coal mines and across time zones into a jungle filled with treacherous cliffs and ravenous green lions. With "her" Doctor - the 7th Doctor - she could have at least been secure in the knowledge that the Doctor had some masterplan. But this new Doctor has no more idea than she does what is going on, and no kind of plan at all!


CHARACTERS

The Doctor: Paul McGann seems to be having a terrific time, infusing his performance with a lot of energy and enthusiasm. As in The TV Movie, he can shift from wild enthusiasm to deadly serious very quickly.  He handles the Doctor's genuine anger at the climax quite well (far better, I'd say, than his immediate predecessor could have done). This story sees him travelling alone, and he reacts with delight at running into an old friend, eager at the thought of travelling with her again.

Bernice Summerfield: Lisa Bowerman has played Bernice for a long time now, both in a handful of Who audios and in her own long-running audio range.  She is likely at the point at which she could play Benny in her sleep. It's to her credit that she does not in any way phone in her performance. The story is very much told from her point-of-view, and as such it is up to her to carry the story. She does so with energy and good humor, and she plays so well opposite McGann that I find myself wanting to hear a full-length release with these two.


THOUGHTS

In the past few years, it has become standard for Big Finish to produce one "anthology" release per year, varying these among their Doctors. 2009 was the 8th Doctor's turn for such a release: The Company of Friends, in which the gimmick was to pair 8th Doctor Paul McGann with companions from the various 8th Doctor ranges: Virgin NA's, BBC EDA's, and the Doctor Who Magazine comic strip. Benny's Story, the first of the four stories, sees the 8th Doctor reunited with the New Adventures' Professor Bernice "Benny" Summerfield.

When I first listened to it, I found this the weakest of the four stories, and I suspect that opinion will hold. That's not to say Benny's Story is bad. It's an amusing trifle, with a great deal of pace and energy and spirited performances by the two leads. But it is very much a trifle, a quick runaround.

The villain is weak, and the scenes in which she tries to take over the TARDIS simply occupy too much of the story's brief running time. I wanted to hear more of the Doctor and Benny, and a lot less of the supremely uninteresting Countess Venhella (Su Douglas), whose only good scene comes when the Doctor confronts her at the end. The plot being just a thin clothesline for interaction between McGann and Bowerman is fine - but if that's the case, then surely we should get as much 8th Doc/Benny as possible?

It's amusing, and worth a listen. But it's too lightweight to be fully satisfying as a story, and too overplotted to be fully satisfying as a character comedy. An OK bit of filler, but nothing more than that.


Rating: 5/10.

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

8th Doctor Audio Review Index

8th Doctor Television Review Index

Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads:

Saturday, January 8, 2011

70. Unregenerate!


4 episodes. Approx. 110 minutes.  Written by: David McIntee. Directed by: John Ainsworth.  Produced by: Gary Russell.


THE PLOT

The Doctor has gone insane.

No, really. He's an inmate of the Klyst Institute, which appears to be a Victorian-era nursing home. The staff are running experiments on their inmates, each of whom has signed an agreement to come here on the day before their deaths. The Doctor apparently interfered with an experiment, resulting in his current condition... though the institute's security chief, Rigan (Gail Clayton) believes the Doctor is just faking it.

Back on Earth, Mel follows a message from the Doctor which leads her to the institute. She knows he must be inside. But when she climbs a tree for a better vantage point, she makes a shocking discovery.

The building is just an empty shell, with no rooms, no doors - not even a real roof!


CHARACTERS

The Doctor: Save for a single, brief scene, the first two episodes show us a Doctor who has lost his mind and his very identity. This might be interesting... but writer David McIntee has chosen to avoid dealing with the insane Doctor, who probably gets a total of 10 minutes' "screen time" across the entire first half of the serial. This is not entirely a bad thing, since "insane acting" not only doesn't play to Sylvester McCoy's strengths, it actually plays directly into his weaknesses! In fairness, McCoy occasionally pitches his voice just right and lets out a perfect line delivery. There's a conversation between the Doctor and Klyst in Part Two, where a few of McCoy's deliveries chill the spine. But most of the time, he's just overacting painfully, warbling his voice in a way that makes it all too easy to picture him pulling bizarre faces. Given that these moments are all we have of the Doctor until well into Part Three, it's... unfortunate, to say the least.

Fortunately, when we do get to see the Doctor being the Doctor, McCoy's performance is much better. When the story flashes back to the Doctor's original involvement with the institute, McCoy is enjoyably in charge. He also does fairly well with an overly-talky climax in Part Four. At least he doesn't mangle any sayings for "comedy" value.

Mel: One positive effect of a relatively "Doctor-lite" story is that Mel is brought front and center. And yes, that is a positive. Mel's character is far better served on audio that it was on television. She's allowed to be smart and proactive, without compromising her basic naivete. She effectively takes charge through most of the story, and she's entirely up to carrying the plot. Bonnie Langford, who really wasn't that bad on television (even in Time and the Rani, the writing was what was wrong with Mel, not the acting), is terrific on audio and obviously enjoys having an actual character to play.


THOUGHTS

I've been a fan of Big Finish's audio Who output for several years now. I think there are only a handful of times in the television run (new or old) in which the average episode quality has been higher than Big Finish's average quality. There are many stories in Big Finish's catalog that I sorely wish had been made for television.

Unregenerate! is not one of those stories.

The story is explicitly set shortly after the Doctor's regeneration, directly following Time and the Rani. If this had been a televised story, that means that McCoy's second serial would have been a story he barely appeared in, with material seemingly tailored to his worst acting traits. It would have been a disastrous follow-up to a disastrous debut, and I'm rather glad this story is effectively an ancillary product.

So, moving beyond the sidelining of the Doctor and McCoy's often-poor performance, the next question: Is the story any good? My answer, sadly, is no. The Doctor's insanity aside, it comes across as a rather generic runaround. Part One gets a lift from the in media res start.  It establishes mysteries that just about carry it through Part Two, though even in Part Two it is clear the story's initial momentum is flagging.

That momentum comes to a dead stop in the serial's second half.  There's some potential in the nature of Klyst's experiments. But that potential is largely unexplored, in favor of a subplot with the tediously one-dimensional Rigan. What little interest the story builds up is easily washed away by a climax in which the characters talk at each other endlessly before one commits a heroic self-sacrifice (TM), followed by more talking.


OVERALL:

As a writer, David McIntee is strong on story structure. Unregenerate! is a competently-told story, and it does actually hang together when all is said and done. From a purely objective standpoint, it is definitely a better story than Time and the Rani.

But for all its faults, there was something vaguely charming about the 7th Doctor's television debut.  It was dreadful, but also bizarrely likable in spite of itself. If nothing else, it had a sense of energy and fun. Unregenerate! has very little energy, and is no fun at all. I know it's slightly the better of the two stories. But I also know that I will watch Time and the Rani again.  I doubt very much that I'll ever again listen to Unregenerate!


Rating: 4/10.

Previous Television Story: Time and the Rani
Next Television Story: Paradise Towers

Search Amazon.com for Doctor Who

7th Doctor Audio Review Index

7th Doctor Television Review Index

Doctor Who Monthly Adventures Review Index

To receive new review updates, follow me:

On BlueSky:

On Threads: